Two new books examining the Flint water crisis, “Flint: The Poisoning of an American City” by Anna Clark and “What the Eyes Don’t See” by Dr. Mona Hanna-Attisha, are criticized for downplaying or misrepresenting the role and motivations of independent scientists who worked to address the crisis. The article argues that both books, while offering valuable accounts of the events and human suffering, unfairly cast doubt on the expertise and integrity of these scientists.
Specifically, the article challenges the books’ portrayals of Marc Edwards, a Virginia Tech professor of civil engineering who played a crucial role in exposing the water contamination. The books are accused of suggesting that Edwards and other scientists were motivated by personal ambition or a desire for publicity, rather than a genuine concern for public health.
The article defends the scientific rigor of Edwards’ work and emphasizes the crucial role he and his team played in uncovering the truth about the lead contamination and holding government officials accountable. It contrasts the books’ skeptical view of these scientists with the evidence of their selfless dedication to resolving the crisis and protecting the residents of Flint. In conclusion, it posits the books reflect a broader trend of skepticism towards scientific expertise.
find the original article here: https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2025/05/16/mcxp-m16.html