Dark Woke: Fighting Hate With Hate Doesn’t Make You Any Better

white and black paper on typewriter

There’s something I want to talk about that I think deserves considerably more attention: Dark Woke.

What exactly is Dark Woke?

Essentially, it’s the practice of taking the attitudes, rhetoric, hostility, prejudice, and general nastiness associated with anti-woke movements and dishing them right back at them. Except this time, the targets are reversed.

Don’t like someone’s political beliefs? Insult them.

Don’t like someone’s identity or background? Make jokes about it.

Don’t like someone’s opinions? Dehumanize them.

Don’t like the people who have spent years making offensive remarks about marginalized communities? Well, now you get to do the same thing to them.

And the justification?

They deserve it.

After all, why should we have to be the bigger person? Why should we extend empathy to people who have demonstrated very little of it themselves? Why should we hold ourselves to standards that our opponents seemingly have no interest in following?

I understand the frustration. I really do.

But here’s the problem: Dark Woke isn’t woke. In fact, it’s practically the opposite.

You’re reproducing the very thing you’re supposedly fighting

Let’s establish something.

Being progressive, supporting social justice, advocating for equality, and challenging discrimination should mean something beyond simply having the correct political affiliations.

It should mean standing against the underlying behaviors and attitudes that contribute to discrimination, prejudice, and dehumanization in the first place.

And that includes standing against those behaviors when they’re directed at people we dislike.

You cannot simultaneously condemn someone for making derogatory remarks about a particular demographic and then turn around and make derogatory remarks about another demographic because you dislike them.

You cannot condemn dehumanization while participating in it yourself.

You cannot criticize people for their intolerance while celebrating your own intolerance.

And you cannot claim to be challenging harmful social dynamics while actively reproducing those same dynamics.

Changing the target doesn’t change the behavior.

Changing the political affiliation doesn’t change the behavior.

Changing which side is delivering the insult doesn’t suddenly make the insult virtuous.

If your entire argument against someone’s behavior is that it’s harmful, then why would you want to replicate it?

The problem goes beyond simply being decent

Now, I want to emphasize something.

This isn’t simply about being polite. It isn’t about maintaining some arbitrary standard of civility at all costs. And it certainly isn’t about suggesting that people should never be angry, confrontational, sarcastic, or offensive.

There are legitimate reasons to be angry. There are legitimate reasons to criticize people harshly. There are circumstances where making someone uncomfortable is entirely justified.

You don’t have to be nice to everyone. You don’t have to tolerate abuse. And you certainly don’t have to pretend that harmful behavior is acceptable.

But there’s a substantial difference between holding people accountable and adopting the very behavior you’re criticizing.

And that’s where Dark Woke becomes particularly concerning.

Because the consequences extend beyond individual interactions.

Dark Woke reinforces the very dynamics and power structures that it supposedly opposes.

Think about it.

When we normalize hostility toward people based on their identities, backgrounds, beliefs, or affiliations, we’re reinforcing the idea that these are acceptable grounds for mistreatment.

When we normalize dehumanizing language, we’re reinforcing the idea that certain people are less deserving of empathy.

When we celebrate humiliation, cruelty, and prejudice simply because they’re directed at people we consider deserving targets, we’re reinforcing the idea that these behaviors are acceptable under the right circumstances.

And when we encourage those behaviors within our own communities, we’re helping ensure that they continue to exist.

That’s the bigger problem.

It isn’t just that Dark Woke is hypocritical. It’s that it actively helps preserve the culture that makes these behaviors possible in the first place.

You aren’t dismantling the machinery. You’re simply changing who’s operating it.

Two wrongs don’t make a right

I don’t care how unpopular this position might be.

I don’t care if some people think I’m being too sympathetic toward people they consider reprehensible.

And I don’t care if people disagree with the message.

Dark Woke should not be encouraged.

We should be better than this.

Not because we need to maintain some pristine moral image. Not because we’re obligated to be endlessly forgiving. And not because people who engage in hateful behavior shouldn’t face consequences.

We should be better because the alternative is perpetuating the exact same problems we’re supposedly trying to solve.

If someone makes an offensive joke about a marginalized community, the answer shouldn’t be to make an equally offensive joke about another community.

If someone dehumanizes their political opponents, the answer shouldn’t be to dehumanize them in return.

If someone engages in prejudice, the answer shouldn’t be to demonstrate that we can be prejudiced toward different people.

We should be challenging the behavior itself.

And that means being willing to challenge it even when it comes from people who agree with us politically.

Especially then.

Because principles that only apply when they’re convenient aren’t particularly meaningful principles.

We need to break the cycle, not perpetuate it

One of the things I find particularly frustrating about modern political discourse is how easily people become comfortable adopting the very attitudes they once condemned.

It’s almost as if the objective has shifted from creating a better society to simply ensuring that the other side experiences the same hostility they’ve inflicted on everyone else.

But is that really progress?

Are we creating a more accepting society by making intolerance acceptable when it’s directed at the right people?

Are we creating a more empathetic society by celebrating the suffering and humiliation of people we disagree with?

Are we dismantling harmful power structures by reproducing their underlying behaviors?

I don’t think so.

And I think we need to be considerably more willing to acknowledge that.

You can be fiercely opposed to someone’s beliefs without treating them as less than human. You can criticize someone’s behavior without making their identity a target. You can hold people accountable without abandoning your own principles.

And you can stand firmly against anti-woke rhetoric without becoming its mirror image.

Ultimately, that’s what this is about.

I’m not interested in replacing one form of hostility with another. I’m interested in challenging the underlying attitudes that make hostility, discrimination, and dehumanization acceptable in the first place.

If we’re only changing who gets to be on the receiving end of hatred, we’re not changing the problem. We’re perpetuating it.

Dark Woke isn’t progress.

It’s just the same old ugliness wearing a different political jersey.

And we should expect better of ourselves.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.